Moving trends see homebuyers paying less money for larger homes

Americans who made out-of-town moves last year typically paid less money for larger houses, according to a new Zillow® analysis of moving data from northAmerican® Van Lines. We’ve got more moving trends below.

That’s a sharp break from the moving trends in recent years. The housing market’s impressive strength in 2020 paired with a newfound motivation to move helped sellers cash in on quickly rising home values to find places that better suit their needs — namely, bigger homes in less-expensive areas.

Movers went to ZIP codes where sold homes are 33 square feet larger on average than where they came from — roughly the size of a walk-in closet or extra bathroom. This was a significant jump from the 9-to 21-square foot step-up movers have taken in recent years.

“The ability to sell in a relatively expensive market and relocate somewhere more affordable — either to save money or get more bang for their buck with a larger property — was extremely attractive to movers,” said Jeff Tucker, senior economist at Zillow. 

Zillow’s recent Mover Report found the top metros for net in-migration, with more people moving in than out, are sunny and relatively affordable. Phoenix, Charlotte and Austin led the U.S. in terms of net in-migration. 

Taken as a whole, the findings are evidence of the Great Reshuffling at work. Up until March 2020, workers were largely locked to locations within a bearable commute of their workplace. When the pandemic hit, many began working remotely — spending a lot more time at home and thinking about where, and how, they want to live. A larger house with an office or chef’s kitchen, or a home with lower monthly payments in sunny Arizona, became extremely alluring.

All the while, interest rates kept dropping, adding fuel to a scorching-hot housing market and boosting shoppers’ buying power. Home appreciation was supercharged in 2020 by massive demand and limited supply, driving typical home values up 8.4% ($20,716) over the course of 2020, compared with 3.7% growth ($8,791) in 2019. 

Tucker said the moving trends could contribute to convergence in home prices, as people move away from the priciest cities and toward more affordable ones, which will tend to cause prices to rise in their destinations. It may also spread out some of the consumer spending, tax revenues and job growth that have been increasingly concentrated in “superstar cities” over the last few decades. Home values are rising fastest in places like Austin and Phoenix, and most slowly in San Francisco, which led the U.S. in appreciation as recently as 2016.

Nationwide, the average home value in ZIP codes people moved from was about $419,000, compared to an average home value in destination ZIP codes of about $392,000. This means the average mover was sliding down the price ladder by about $27,000. When movers relocated in 2019, average home values in their destinations were only about $3,400 less than where they started. 

The trend in 2020 to move to more affordable places than in years past was seen across nearly every type of move between urban, suburban and rural areas. People leaving urban ZIP codes moved to areas that were $66,000 cheaper in 2020, versus an average of about $26,000 cheaper in the previous four years. Those leaving suburban ZIPs moved about $23,000 down the price ladder, compared to an average decrease of just over $500 the previous four years.

Even those leaving rural areas for urban or suburban areas, where prices are higher, only moved up the price ladder by about $31,000 this year as opposed to roughly $41,000 in recent years.

“We have felt the impact of this supercharged market since the second half of 2020.  These migration patterns are challenging the moving industry to provide capacity in the right places.  As you would expect, we end up with a lot of trucks in the low-cost areas where people are moving to, and fewer trucks in the high-cost areas where demand is high,” said Kevin Murphy, Vice President and General Manager of northAmerican Van Lines. “It is more important than ever to make sure you have a reliable partner helping you with your move.”  

Migration to less urban areas picked up slightly in 2020 compared to 2019, while moves to more dense locations ticked down — which is not to say that early pandemic fears of an urban exodus have been borne out. The number of households that moved out of urban areas did not significantly rise in 2020. Beyond that, Zillow’s Urban-Suburban report found that despite some early pandemic-era narratives, suburban housing markets did not disproportionately strengthen in 2020 at the expense of urban areas. 

The biggest decrease in share of moves between area classes was from suburban to urban, which fell 1.5% year over year. The largest increase was seen in suburban to rural moves, which increased by 1.2% on the year. 

San Jose saw the most extreme changes in average home value for both those moving to and from ZIP codes within the metro, followed by San Francisco and Los Angeles. Those moving out of San Jose went to a ZIP with average home values nearly $1.2 million lower, while those moving in saw houses worth about $1.4 million more than where they came from. 

Moving on Up – Americans’ Preferences for Larger Homes, 2016-2020

Load Year20162017201820192020
Ave. SF Origin ZIP1,8401,8621,8581,8561,880
Ave. SF Destination ZIP1,8561,8711,8781,8781,913
Ave. SF Change, Origin to Destination ZIP169202133
Metropolitan  Area*Zillow Home 
Value Index 
(ZHVI); April, 
Year over 
Ave. ZHVI 
Change for 
Moving In
Ave. ZHVI 
Change for 
those Moving 
Ave. SF 
for those 
Ave. SF 
for those 
United States$281,37011.6%($26,963)($26,963)3333
New York, NY$530,0829.5%$144,774($158,981)8371
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA$783,61010.4%$614,793($591,517)(113)269
Chicago, IL$270,3529.5%($85,080)$89,775(55)135
Dallas-Fort Worth, TX$289,58211.9%($61,326)$28,762468(369)
Philadelphia, PA$288,94713.3%($82,866)$46,65655(27)
Houston, TX$241,6989.1%($69,253)$59,995451(449)
Washington, DC$498,64911.5%$146,141($135,203)(71)159
Miami-Fort Lauderdale, FL$336,7149.1%($144,164)$74,801(264)331
Atlanta, GA$280,03813.0%($63,161)$31,392374(293)
Boston, MA$563,14911.6%$190,243($170,429)(60)131
San Francisco, CA$1,235,7057.4%$856,457($815,525)(129)274
Detroit, MI$209,72811.0%($107,479)$119,830(64)112
Riverside, CA$460,83316.2%$46,162($92,823)8517
Phoenix, AZ$355,82220.4%($48,237)($27,012)116(55)
Seattle, WA$627,29014.6%$260,754($264,337)(56)105
Minneapolis-St Paul, MN$331,1529.9%($76,075)$75,69079(8)
San Diego, CA$729,31816.5%$396,605($422,781)(235)236
St. Louis, MO$205,60411.5%($95,351)$112,8495615
Tampa, FL$271,35315.8%($79,814)$73,756(196)253
Baltimore, MD$332,99211.2%($28,097)$64,057(35)153
Denver, CO$517,39512.9%$66,326($141,738)273(264)
Pittsburgh, PA$185,06313.0%($143,326)$138,316(136)205
Portland, OR$482,70813.3%($68,322)($9,567)(42)99
Charlotte, NC$281,33514.4%($65,427)$63,422296(220)
Sacramento, CA$507,73514.3%$90,214($128,023)(77)49
San Antonio, TX$233,08310.4%($77,521)$52,586216(228)
Orlando, FL$285,0498.3%($89,488)$64,618(31)78
Cincinnati, OH$218,67214.6%($102,691)$123,198(53)76
Cleveland, OH$184,22413.5%($197,369)$204,956(183)(31)
Kansas City, MO$241,20314.6%($74,845)$68,806315(291)
Las Vegas, NV$330,8809.4%($112,481)$18,096(23)41
Columbus, OH$244,22012.4%($102,017)$111,565(90)81
Indianapolis, IN$212,33413.7%($96,710)$124,727565(464)
San Jose, CA$1,364,2735.9%$1,357,893($1,160,458)(74)212
Austin, TX$441,93125.5%($100,567)$1,194130(100)
Virginia Beach, VA$275,56210.3%($65,907)$48,7288451
Nashville, TN$320,81811.0%($50,689)($9,082)259(261)
Providence, RI$375,40715.0%($41,939)$15,290(63)118
Milwaukee, WI$232,74413.9%($116,431)$128,666(131)154
Jacksonville, FL$265,10511.7%($60,580)$89,408(24)95
Memphis, TN$182,19413.2%($46,734)$96,938428(349)
Oklahoma City, OK$175,9228.9%($187,063)$140,522(98)101
Louisville-Jefferson County, KY$205,64710.6%($85,923)$82,197(102)117
Hartford, CT$274,46813.6%($125,603)$104,594(92)66
Richmond, VA$279,33610.5%($69,034)$36,317212(154)
New Orleans, LA$231,2249.1%($128,363)$77,837(99)153
Buffalo, NY$202,04014.1%($140,212)$125,141(141)107
Raleigh, NC$327,04812.3%($69,436)$51,024370(272)
Birmingham, AL$195,64310.7%($46,066)$71,670116(178)
Salt Lake City, UT$466,76818.3%$9,323($47,652)(20)34